Russell Brand: From Addiction to Recovery

2012 ,    »  -   75 Comments
2.9k
8.31
12345678910
Ratings: 8.31/10 from 318 users.
Storyline
Russell Brand: From Addiction to Recovery

Cannabis, booze, acid, speed, coke, crack, heroin... Russell took drugs every single day. At one point he started being afraid of the fact that he might die. He was told that if he continues like that, in six month time, he's going to be dead, in prison, or in an asylum. He got clean at the age of 27, the age Amy Winehouse was when she died. Amy's death was a paradoxical, unsurprising shock, and Russell felt like he could have done something to help.

That's why he made this film, to have a sympathetic look at alcoholism and addiction, a condition that the World Health Organization regards as a disorder. He reckons that drugs and alcoholism are much misunderstood by users, non-users, and the government. He thinks that we need to start regarding addiction in all its forms as a health issue as opposed to the judicial and criminal issue. In this film he wants to learn more and see if we can do things differently.

Brand meets a whole range of people from whom he draws insights - scientists at the cutting edge of research into the psychology of addiction, those involved in innovative recovery treatments and drug addicts themselves.

Is addiction a disease? Should it be criminalized? And is abstinence-based recovery, which worked for Brand, a possible way forward? In this documentary Brand challenges conventional theory and practice as well as government policy in his own inimitable style, confronting the reality of addiction head on.

Along the way he draws on his own experience to try to help one of the addicts he meets to take the first steps towards recovery. Armed with his own heartfelt beliefs and new insights gained during his journey, Brand has the opportunity to change the hearts and minds of policy makers when he is invited to give evidence before the Home Affairs Select Committee investigating the efficacy of current drug addiction treatment in the UK. - BBC Three.

More great documentaries

75 Comments / User Reviews

  1. Pysmythe

    Made me a little nervous for Brand, watching him around all those drugs he used to use. I'd agree with him, though, that better efforts to address the addiction could also reduce a good deal of the crime that so often goes along with it... Who could argue with that, really? It does appear that when the state treats addicts as criminals, it ends up costing it more money in the long run, and yet I know the problem isn't that simple. For sure, you can't just let people get away with crime, but the Brighton (Brighton, England! What an unexpected, lovely surprise!) Police Chief himself said that 80% of acquisitive crime there is ultimately due to addiction, so something somewhere isn't working as well as one could hope. All I know is, if I could work miracles, I'd be one of the best miracle workers you could ever hope for, and no one, anywhere, would ever have to suffer a life like that.

  2. Space_Cadet_1952

    Being from Brighton, I often comment on the fact that,: 'Brighton has the appellation of being the Drug Death Capital of the UK'. However, the main problem, as has been clearly demonstrated by this documentary, is that it is a war of Capitalism versus Socialism. Socialism for the rich and Capitalism for the poor. A telling point was where a person in authority said, "I wouldn't put my daughter on Methadone, I would have her treated in a rehab clinic'. Rightly, if one is an addict - unable to control consumption - then the only treatment may well be abstinence. The other serious issue was that of 'emotional articulation' of the problem or problems of the individual - often deeply buried in their past.

    We live in a world where the pursuit of pleasure over-rides self respect. Many people don't know what self respect is, until their self-destructive behaviour is pointed out to them .

    Finally, as Russell said, and I am a big advocate, 'Love and compassion' is the key. That is very hard to implement In a world dominated by the worst addiction of all... a love and addictive worship of money – and the willingness to ride roughshod over everybody to get it. In other words, the people who run the system, who control the purse strings, and the money markets. They are the worst, most socially destructive addicts of all. For them, there is no recognised need for treatment, because they control the system.

  3. Pysmythe

    Pretty much agree with you on all points, especially the love and compassion part. These are not BAD people, I feel, so much as people who have probably simply not learned how to live in the world, between one thing and another, in addition to having a probable genetic predisposition to it. But I would add that I don't personally believe a person would necessarily have to even have some trauma in their past, OR a genetic predisposition, in order for them to decide to use drugs and alcohol heavily, and so perhaps end up in very deep trouble. People have always been into chemically modifying their perceptions in some way, anyway, for religious or recreational purposes, primarily. But make a world as cold as this one, as you rightly point out, and is it much of a wonder that a lot of people choose the selfish route of opting out of it in some of the easiest ways short of suicide? There is failure and blame enough to go around on all sides here, not just on the part of the addict, even if his choices are ultimately the ones he has to make. People like to feel good, but that is not what life is solely supposed to be about, is it? But there are ways of achieving a good feeling that don't require so much sacrifice... For example, it's snowing here in the northeastern U.S. today for the next twelve hours or so, and I think I'll bundle myself up nice and snug and take a long walk in it up to the corner store for a cup of coffee. I like that, because the world is quiet, the traffic is light, and it's just the wind and the flakes and a careful step. Simple things like that is one of the things I most pity the addicts for, since I doubt their embattled brains skewered levels of dopamine allow them to enjoy them.

  4. Imightberiding

    I thought Russel Brand's appearance before the Home Affairs Select Committee was cohesive, more impressive than I anticipated & hopefully most of all effective.

    The most visceral point of this documentary for me was when he was interviewing the two women in their living room. The titillation, as he explained afterward, that he experience while handling their kit & drugs, seemed absolutely palpable. The fulcrum in his conversation with them & his own sobriety was when one of them stated: "You don't have to worry because you know you will never use again." & Russel turned to her & with an intense look & strained tone of voice responded: "No I don't." (paraphrased conversation)

    Good on Russel Brand for making this film. I trust it wasn't just an act of contrition & penance for his past "sins". He genuinely seems sincere. I hope he reaches many people in need of help & enables positive change in their lives. More power to him.

    *Edit* @ the moderators: My apologies if an earlier response to a comment was not appropriate. (I see it is gone) It was not intended to be an attack on the commenter, it's just that I found his manifesto to be a little off-putting.

  5. jaberwokky

    Rehab for the Rich, Methadone for the poor.

    I think that line above ... ^^ ... should be the banner used to point out the inequalities between "us and them". I hate making that definition between our social classes but sometimes there is nothing else that works.

    You're very right in a lot of what you say except ... socialism for the rich only extends as far as spreading their debts amongst the lower classes. Socializing debt. Not really full spectrum socialism but if I'm right I think that may have been your point.

  6. jaberwokky

    I loved this doc and also think it hits on some points that are often conveniently missed/overlooked. For example the Methadone for the poor and Rehab for the Rich thing. It might seem like a small thing but as a former habitual character I assure you it's not.

    I remember a few years back how much I disliked Russell Brand and how I thought he was a vacuous blow-hard, waste of space cock-bag and symptomatic of what the TV Zeitgeist was about. How times have changed. John Steward aside, there are very few media people that grab my attention this much nowadays. Obviously Russell still has issues with regards to the amount of attention his ego needs but I have no hesitation in over-looking that if he keeps his motormouth geared the way it is at the moment.

  7. jaberwokky

    Spot on man, it really is how we choose to address the addiction. Unfortunately it looks like its one of those changes that has to come from the ground up ... we'll be waiting a while.

  8. a_no_n

    i disagree with his views toward addiction being a disease...that's nonsense peddled by cults like AA and in my mind is akin to sugarcoating the situation. Addiction is not a disease, and it's also wrong that people consider themselves to always be addicts even though they've been clean and sober for x years. This is a defining symptom of a cult, something that forces you to live a life that involves never letting go.

    Abstinence based recovery groups like AA have a mindbogglingly low success rate, only 5%. for every hundred people that go through AA, only 5 make it the whole way through! That's exactly the same chance you have of succeeding on your own. This is hard to find out because they don't publish their rates of success, for this very reason. My figure comes from the episode of 'Penn and Tellers Bullsh*t' on this very subject.

    Abstinence based rehab organizations like AA are cults in every definition of the word. as already mentioned they worm their way into your life as a permenant fixture. They prey on vulnerable people, often people who are forced to their clutches by courts, and then they break them down until they accept pretty much no responsibility for their life, with pathetic excuses like "it's a disease" and then they force their victims to become a slave to an unspecified "higher power" That's right, Athieists need not apply, if you're an addicted athieist you're pretty much screwed because AA will refuse to help you until you recant your athieism, which it treats like a part of the "Disease"...in any other place in the western world that would be called a forced conversion and it would be illegal, but for the cult of AA it's A-ok!

    All the same though, however he did it if it worked for him then fair play. i'm glad he got through it and was able to start doing what he wanted with his life but people ought to know the truth behind these awful organizations..

  9. Space_Cadet_1952

    To paraphrase Russel Brand's unusual humility, "If it weren't for my entertainment career I'd be back on the drugs", which proves the point that in order to break destructive habits we all need 'a mission'. In this case, to educate fellow sufferers away from life wasting habits and certain death.

  10. Space_Cadet_1952

    A similar argument is made by religious people regarding Albert Einstein's comment, "I want to know the mind of God''. Which was his metaphor for trying to understand the unfathomable nature of the universe, in his attempt to formulate a 'theory of everything'. Most scientists are atheists or at worst agnostic.

  11. Pysmythe

    Yeah, he's really getting through to me lately, but I used to be annoyed by him, too. That ego, he's such a rock star, lol. I keep picturing him with a pre-CBS tobacco-burst strat slung across his back, Joe Perry style.

  12. xxDarkSidexx

    not to sure about having a mission, what about addicts that have families? surely thats the ultimate mission, it's hard to say really, i'm a smoker, have a wife and 3 year old son, can't give up smoking even though deep down inside me i need to do it for them, it's the "i'll start next week" now if I went to a doctor and he told me I was going to die next week, I think that would make me stop.

  13. Steve the workers advocate

    His career is dead another publicity stunt, lets see just about %50 of the population uses cannabis, booze and many teens and twenty somethings do acid no all the time, many people used coke at parties. Let lie detector to see if he used or tried crack and heroin, tried is
    most likely it or he would still have some issues. Nice publicly
    stunt I guess anything for money now Russell acting is done hmm.

  14. jaberwokky

    Definitely, it'd go well with his shirts and stubble. Can't see him hefting a Les Paul around the gaff on his merry adventures, not with those scrawny limbs :)

  15. Space_Cadet_1952

    'A mission' can be anything you want it to be, including giving up smoking. Or getting a job after a long period of unemployment - which allows one to hold one's head up in society, and set our children a good example, instead of feeling like a weakling and making them feel ashamed of us. Any job is better than sitting at home watching television, and feeling useless. I have known lots of unemployment, as a plumber in the benighted building industry.

    I have been an on-and-off smoker since the age of 14. I gave up completely about two months ago and told my new partner of 11 months, "I want us to have as long and healthy a relationship together as possible. I have decided to stop because I realise that I am tempting fate. Besides, if we are going to have lots of holidays around the world in the future, I need to be as fit as I can be". She replied, "What, not even the odd Havana cigar"? I said, "That's a difficult one – maybe once a year on our anniversary, but in principle 'no'".

    I have been neglecting my gym also, this past couple of years. My waistline, and blood pressure, are paying the price.

    My paternal grandfather died of pneumonia at 75 - he was a lifelong smoker. My mother and her sister died of cancer before their 60th birthdays - both were heavy smokers. I'm nearly 62.

    All I did was simply stop. I'm sure Russell Brand would agree with me, "We need to make a firm decision, and stick to it". It does not require any thinking, just deciding, and remaining unwavering. After about a week the desire quickly leaves. It's about finding self respect, and being an adult, instead of remaining as a substance based, emotionally-dependent 'child'.

  16. Space_Cadet_1952

    What are you on, man? Fail to score this week?

  17. bringmeredwine

    Good for you and best of luck in your future endeavours!

  18. bringmeredwine

    Its -35 degrees Celsius today where I live. Really missing my long walks in the woods with my evil little dog.
    On milder days my walks mean the world to me too.
    Enjoy!

  19. Space_Cadet_1952

    Thanks for your kind wishes - and Merry Christmas to you too =)

  20. Steve the workers advocate

    You like him, he was interesting to hear years ago
    but the same thing grows old, there is something called Heroin water a mixture un flavored alcohol and
    unprocessed tar from heroin poppy, used with great
    success in Iran to stop alcoholics and heroin users from using, a small glass or bottle will allow them to
    get through the day as a normal person without the
    urge for getting drunk or spaced out on heroin.
    I find it hard to believe he was a heroin addict maybe
    a person who tried or smoked opium.

  21. Steve the workers advocate

    They need can eventually get clean they have to leave the scene this is where treatment comes in, by having a place they can get
    something that is the closest thing to a fix be it alcohol or heroin, they won't go back to the dealer. When they are ready they go cold turkey after they are out of the scene, let them
    return for heroin water it will allow them to stumble but not fall and eventually get clean WITH HELP THEY NEED SOMEONE WHO
    CAN AND WILL HELP THEM STAND UP AGAIN.

  22. Space_Cadet_1952

    You can't get 'heroin water' in this country as part of legitimate treatment, to my knowledge.

    You sound as though you need help yourself.

    Unfortunately, TopDocumentaryFilm comments is not the place. Get qualified help, whoever you are. There are lots of clinics across the country. Choose your own way, but make a choice, stick to it, and see it through. Good luck.

  23. Steve the workers advocate

    Dude I don't touch any drugs even when the doctor say take this I say no, I live organic.

    Heroin water is used in Iran with great success, it's cheaper and one of the most effective treatments it also allows governments to buy tar heroin from farmers for better prices than the farmers sell to the illegal processors, two birds with one stone.
    Cannabis is the best choice for many issues
    George Washington and the American founders and farmers grew and smoked it
    until the early 1900's when Dupont and Harry
    Anslinger wanted to make big cash and
    did what others had done paid people off to lie.

    In NYC many cops use the N word all the
    time then they block off a poor street a
    for stop and frisk some young teenage black kid doesn't want to get in trouble from his parents so he runs, they shoot him in the back
    and Bloomberg and Kelly lie to cover it up
    they recruit others for the job as well.
    Bloomberg is a hardcore racist he want to finger print all low income people in NYC
    most of them black after a shooting he never cares someone family member was wrongly shot he doesn't care. The second a rocket is shot at the Israelis he is up in arms and the rocket is brought to the Mayors office in NYC and is on TV. Our bodies have developed over millions of years with Cannabis and has specially developed receptors for Cannabis,
    This would be the best choice for you if you
    suffer, High THC or High CBD(doesn't get you high) Cannabis the ancients until the 1900
    developed strains to take on Cancer , Brain Damage, Pain, sizers, tumors, pleasure and
    yes addiction. I'm sure heroin addicts could find one that will help them stay clean.

  24. Bella Button

    Best addiction documentary I've ever seen !!!

  25. Space_Cadet_1952

    Forgive me Steve, but it is not always clear to me what point you are making, due to your unusual choice of grammar, syntax or context.

    That aside, in Brighton you can smell cannabis being smoked in the street almost everywhere you go in Kemp Town and central Brighton.

    I get the impression that while it may be frowned on by Brighton's 'Rainbow' police, it's only the dealers they're after. (Brighton, apart from being the Drug Death Capital, is also the Gay Capital of Britain, with a separate squad made up of 'gays' to break up GLBT domestic fights - to add to its distinct character. Again, we are 'off topic', but then libertarianism tends to go hand in hand with unconventional lifestyles).

    This country has an ambivalent attitude to cannabis, but every day kids are reported to have died from all sorts of recreational drugs, including a single Ecstasy pill. Some have been promising university students, and died or became paraplegic. So, although medical accidents happen all the time, young people have little concept of the often fatal dangers of dodgy gear, distributed by unscrupulous dealers.

    US Police shooting black people in the back is a whole separate issue. I think you are referring to racism, which is a different ball game, and an enormous political and social minefield in America.

    America was built on the destruction of the indigenous population, and its wealth was borne on the backs of its millions of mostly black slaves. I believe that all the Founding Fathers were slave owners. However, the Chinese, along with the Irish, didn't get much better treatment building the Transcontinental rail roads in the 19th century. America has always been rife with stupefying inequality, from sub-prime mortgages to mostly black neighbourhoods, and ongoing Chinese mainland slavery in New York's China Town, to sex-trade human trafficking sourced from Eastern Europe.

  26. bringmeredwine

    Hi DarkSide, sorry to "butt" in but having a family should definitely be a good enough reason to quit drugs.
    Getting pregnant a thousand years ago compelled me to quit smoking immediately. I couldn't bear the thought of all those toxins getting into my baby's bloodstream!
    Like a dolt head, I started smoking again when my kids became older (but only on social occasions away from them).
    Years later I smoke like a chimney again; however I'm now using e-cigarettes when I'm around nonsmokers. They're great but I still wish I could just give up the whole disgusting habit.
    I enjoyed using drugs recreationally in my youth but gave them all up when I had to step up to the plate and be a responsible adult.
    Thank goodness I was never addicted to them.

  27. bringmeredwine

    Russell Brand is annoying, but his doc expressed so powerfully what I have been thinking for years.
    I've watched suboxone (an extremely expensive drug treatment)) and methadone add fuel to the downward spiral of the ones I love.
    Where I live its 15,000 dollars per month for private treatment, and you're still put on methadone.
    The publicly funded programs are nearly impossible to get into, and they too dole out the legal drugs, and the addicts I know, can't or won't stop taking them.
    The makers of methadone et al must be making billions of dollars!
    Amy's music throughout this doc was very haunting and moving. I got the sense that she was urging along Brand's message.

  28. Space_Cadet_1952

    When in doubt, follow the money.

  29. Pysmythe

    Excuse me, Brighton... is the GAY capital of England?? Oh, sh-t! Lololol, that explains all the cakes and tarps!

  30. Space_Cadet_1952

    One could say somewhere has to be 'it'. However, I'm not clear on the connection with 'explaining all the cakes and tarps'. What is that supposed to be a euphemism for?

  31. Pysmythe

    Effeminacy and an "inordinate love" of pretty things, which seem rather common in the (male) gay community, not that there's anything wrong with that. I once heard it used by a friend of mine, from Brighton, in reference to the city, though they may very well not have intended it to convey what I have. Mostly I find it funny only because Brighton being the "gay capital of England" potentially casts my earlier comment of an "unexpected, lovely surprise" in a light in which I did not intend it, either.
    Good enough? :)

  32. dewfall

    Cupcakes and bunting ;)

  33. Pysmythe

    THAT was it, thank you! :)

  34. dewfall

    I'm liking yours better :)

  35. Pysmythe

    Urban dictionary: Tarp. A female with a penis.

    This is one of those co-inky-dinks that Carl Jung would have loved, I'm thinking, lol.

  36. Space_Cadet_1952

    This is getting to be a very surreal and somewhat Freudian post...

    Being an aficionado of the Royal Navy: flag signallers are known as 'Bunting Tossers'. It just gets worse...

  37. Space_Cadet_1952

    Correction:
    Brighton (and Hove 'Actually') is the gay capital of the UK, not just England. You will hear camp: N Ireland, Welsh and Scottish voices amongst the throng of Polari-speaking denizens of Kemp Town. Several times in the last few years I have bumped into Scottish, Mr Jimmy Sommerville of the groups, Bronski Beat ('Smalltown Boy', 1984) and The Communards, ('Don't Leave Me This Way' 1987), these songs being his biggest hits. The scary part is that after nearly 30 years, aged 52, he is still as young looking as he was then. He seems to be always smiling, perhaps because he likes being recognised in a more accepting community.

    Nice to see that you are, like Vin Diesel, John Travolta and George Clooney, willing to acknowledge your 'feminine side'.

    Personally, living surrounded by it, I'm not even bi-curious. If it's very tall with slender legs, slim hips, high heels, heavy make up, a skin-tight dress with a big, bouffant hairdo, shrieking at the top of its voice in Kemp Town, it's probably a bloke cruising for Saturday night jollies.

  38. Steve the workers advocate

    GLBT Why do the police care about gays

    are they picked on by police in England.
    The stop and search in NYC is more gestapo when these guys are around everyone fears
    being shot for any reason.
    Cannabis is like beer it's natural and from nature, don't use any illegal drugs, all legal
    drugs should not be taken as well they kill your liver. Stay organic you will feel better you want to smoke a little cannabis or drink a beer OK else no hard drugs or alcohol legal or not and eat Butternut Squash 3 days a week.

  39. dewfall

    A lot of those around lately!

  40. Pysmythe

    I honestly had no idea that was the urban dictionary definition until I decided to check on the "sub-definition" after your last post. I think I actually intended to say "awning," which would have at least been closer to the image I wanted to convey, but I love these sorts of serendipitous things, too. The hand of the Prime Comedian at work!

  41. moarl

    How can people talk down on Russell? This documentary was brilliant in all ways and you need to understand that it's impossible to talk about every issue concerning drug abuse in 1h.
    He is clearly a man who cares about others aswell as the big picture.

    Shame on you.

  42. feudipandola

    You nailed it! Any man who dumps Kate Perry is not wrapped too tight. Brand is like so many addicts...funny as hell on dope but once he's clean, he's BORING! Really, really boring.

  43. a_no_n

    move from cigarettes to a pipe...you won't regret it.

  44. jess

    I find the your comment to be quite extreme and dare I say, most of what you are expressing is wrong in my eyes. Which I find baffling because you are so passionate about it. I must ask the question, are you an addict or an alcoholic? You must have had some exposure to these support groups . It is not true that AA/NA are cults. They are support groups for people who suffer from addiction. They are a safe place for people to share their stories and struggles. Struggles that continue long after the drugs and alcohol are put down. For many people support is a lifelong thing because it is not easy to stay clean. If it were easy, everybody could do it. A five per cent success rate is not a reflection of an unsuccessful program, it is a reflection of an extremely powerful illness. It is not true that atheists are not welcome at 12 step fellowships. The steps are optional to work with, and spirituality can mean a lot of things. I know many atheists in the rooms. I whole heartedly disagree with you that support groups for addicts are 'awful organisations'. I have seen the good that comes from them. It is essential for most people in recovery that they have the ongoing support that these groups offer. Connecting with other like minded people who are focused on recovery on a regular basis is of significant help to staying clean. Many people make the mistake of believing that addiction is something that can be cured, 'fixed' at a certain point. This isn't so. It takes maintenance and ongoing work. The only condition of being apart of these groups is the desire to live a clean life and this in no way reflects a cult. For some people it is easier to deduce the groups as unhelpful and ludicrous rather than stick around long enough to understand. I am a recovering addict and I myself required long term rehabilitation in order to build myself a strong enough foundation in order to stay clean. But that's the gift rehab has been able to give me. Recovery from addiction is ongoing, it is a life long commitment and this is what scares a lot of people away. I know it scared me in the beginning. And I also know that 12 step fellowships frightened me a lot as well. I myself fell into a critical analysis of them but I couldn't see their benefit because I was so unwell and closed minded to what it meant to be an addict.
    It is very untrue that these organisations allow people to accept no responsibility in their lives. In recovery we learn to take responsibility and cease blaming others. There is a difference between blaming situations and taking no responsibility and admitting the reality of a situation so as to learn more about the psychological impacts it may have had.
    I find what you said at the end of your comment quite interesting. 'people ought to know the truth behind these awful organisations'. What you have stated is your truth. Your perspective. As what I have stated is mine. But I guess the next thing I'd like you to think about is what impact you are making by spreading something which is clearly not evidence based across the internet, and potentially damaging other peoples chance of accessing support networks for their addictions. I am making a very educated assumption in saying that what you have said isn't evidence based, because I believe that I have experienced enough of 12 step fellowships to understand the truth behind them.
    And I think Russell has done a great thing by creating this documentary. I do not pretend to know the truth about HIS situation, whether he is seeking publicity or not, he is promoting a good cause and using the power and publicity he has access to to do so. I can't see how that could be something worth criticising. He has a great understanding of addiction. He does know what he is talking about. Abstinence based recovery is the only way to access recovery from addiction. I hope he keeps up the good work.

  45. Canzara

    Methadone and cure used in the same sentence?
    ABSOLUTELY HILLARIOUS!
    Grab yourself some knowledge

  46. Canzara

    I think you read too many books and don't go outside enough so that the knowledge you got from books, can coincide with the real world.

  47. Sky

    Yah anyone I ever met that did crack or heroin is still a junkie, dead, or in jail. It's doubtful Brand was a junkie for any serious length of time beyond pills. I've known some successful abstinence people who quit for life, but the sort of will involved is beyond someone living a social life in the limelight. Abstinence is really not a solution for the common man. You have to have steel resolve and the average person in the world is a coffee swilling, mcdonalds scarfing, weak-willed, television tool. Abstinence is like, (in my estimation?) possible for maybe .01% of the hard drug junkies out there. That SORT OF nullifies the point behind this doc. Sort of. They'd do better to spend minimal time pointing out that abstinence is only possible for a miniscule percentage of the world pop? Then move on, and talk about therapy, self strength, and the long hard daily path out of the darkness back into the light. And the many likely relapses that will occur and the struggles that come with any sort of human interest hardship. Preaching perfection and idolizing someone for it totally obfuscates the actual reality. Its just as bad as making junk appear glamourous, it will take people down very dark paths.

  48. Sky

    Thats right. Lets cure heroin addiction? With heroin water. You don't seem to understand the inherant fallacy in the logic or something? It's pretty simple. You listening to yourself before you speak? The simplest logic defeats any and all points you could ever make about weening. Same goes for the establishment. They know exactly why they still do the methadone. Because it doesn't work and it just keeps people hanging on, it fosters relapse. "Perfect Day" by Lou Reed comes to mind. Im not saying absitince is the cure either because it isnt. But I am saying the one socially acceptable cure for heroin addiction that is currently prevalent in society is not a cure at all. But just the same disease watered down and fed to the masses. Much more research needs to be done. BAN METHADONE AND HEROIN WATER

  49. a_no_n

    Congratulations, you're one of the five percent...Addiction is not a disease pure and sinple, Cancer is a disease, Parkinsons is a disease, Altzheimers is a disease. Addiction is just that, an addiction.

    Calling addiction a disease is an excuse, a way of shifting blame.

    You've got a lot of nerve accusing me of not using evidence after that long winded reel of opinions you just fired at me...I pointed you to one of my sources...i bet you didn't go and check it out before questioning my evidence did you?

    Look, i'm not having a go at people who manage to succeed, but for every person like you that does succeed there are ninety people at least who fall through the cracks...I'll accept my opinions might be extreme and as a result inaccurate, but you also need to realise that you have some serious rose tinted glasses on about the practice.

    I'm yet to see abstinence work as a therapy for anything, it certainly doesn't work for pregnancy, and the results suggest it doesn't work for addiction either.

    5% is not a passing grade!

  50. william brown

    lots of love and respect for russell brand caring about addicts...being an addict myself it is really important to feel that people care and love about you

  51. terrasodium

    This is an interesting study of marginalizatiion, step one find a hack celebretard, step two produce a series of public broadcasts with celebretard as simpathetic to various good causes, step three throw the messages into the echo chamber until most of the public identifies the messages with the celebretard without seperation of the two,step four put the celebetard on the highest platform that the medias can build , step five kick the platform out from under the celebretard until the public identifies the celebretard as a hypocrite and a crackpot, step six when any conversation comes to public discourse regarding forementioned good causes conterarguements only need mention celebretards name to ridicule any discourse that may bring some real response by any mass actions to fix a purposely broken social system that pays , no boogie man = no boogie man hunters.boogie man laws are a savy lawyers rainmaking payday.

  52. jaberwokky

    Kate Perry is nothing special man, have you ever listened to her talk or do you prefer your female company to have their cakehole tightly closed? And if you were anyway politically bent you would not be making such flippant remarks regarding Russell.

  53. kafka11

    great doc, highlighting the scandal of sending addicts to methadonia for life, govt funded recovery especially under Labour was about the 'money'. A heroin client is a cash cow that brings in revenue for the pharma companies and for the services, a client that uses the services in a revolving door way is brings in regular income as opposed to one that gets clean and sober and does not return. The NTA has a track success record of nearly zero, meaning that all the millions spent on methadone treatment has simply been wasted.
    The comments questioning Russel Brands motives are disgusting and frankly only highlight the shocking lack of insight most people have in the UK, the US are light years ahead of us and see abstinence based programmes as a given. How dare people question Brands honesty and commitment to this issue, you are a bunch of armchair cavemen.

  54. kafka11

    mate you are a dick, so the guy goes to treatment for a publicity stunt.? Could you not see the feeling and passion in the guys eyes. This s*it means a lot to the man, or were you to knocked off to notice.

  55. kafka11

    WTF has Kate Perry got to do with this doc, what are you 12 years old, get a life.

  56. kafka11

    imagine giving an alcoholic a miniature bottle of vodka a day and saying 'off you go and recover'. An addict should be given the opportunity to get clean and all the support that comes with that. If they feel they are not ready, FINE, come back when you are ready to get CLEAN, now move over and let someone who does want to get CLEAN use the resources.

  57. Richard Passley

    hahahah - Professor David Nut, hit the nail on the head when he (basically said.) "another reason why people get addicted to drugs is because they're good."

    It's a harsh truth, BUT the truth. I've never done heroine before and (fingers crossed.) NEVER will. However, if you talk the most crack cocaine and heroine addicts, the vast majority will tell you that the reason why they are addicted to those drugs is because they're trying to chase/recreate that 1st ever hit the drug gave them. However and little do they know, that 1st hit is as good as it gets. Hence why those particular drugs are so addictive. Don't be naive, the high they give the user is that good.

    I do fully believe that another reason why people get addicted to drugs is because there is a void in their lives OR the user is trying to block something out of their life. You don't have to have worked in social services to realise that many people addicted to drugs have experienced very traumatic things in their lives.

    So how does the UK and the world deal with this drug problem? Again, the truth is, they can't. Again, many people don't realise that the "war on drugs" is one of the biggest scams EVER going. The Issue of drugs is obviously a huge vote winner for ANY Politician willing to to tell bare faced lies to the public, saying how they're willing to do this, that and the other to keep your kids safe!

    IF the politician was genuine in his/her cursaude in this "war on drugs", why is the UK and other places on earth now awash with drugs? They're the politician's. They ultimately designed the rules and laws of the land?

    Correct me IF I'm wrong but there is a war, currently raging in Afghanistan, the same place where (it's something like.) 70%+ of the world's opium is to be found. Why not devastate the poppy fields? That's a real "war on drugs!" Some heroine addict in the documentary basically say's, "this methadone programme does not work."

    Wake up lad. You're NOT supposed to be helped! Your a potential massive vote winner when/If a brain dead politician is desperate for votes. They just bring up the "war on drugs" slogan, your face & desperate plight to "help" other kids going down the same road by getting their parents to vote for them.

    So, what's the best way to defeat this drug problem. Just try and stay strong and keep away from them. Just remember, once you become addicted the harsh truth is:

    1.) they are good

    2.) you're not supposed to be helped! you've now allowed yourself to become in nothing more than a pawn in game, a game you probably didn't even know existed and that you NOW very much apart of - until you read this post.

  58. Richard Passley

    You're spot on. Peaching "abstinence" to a crack or smack head is just bang out of order. This is because it is a well known FACT that (certainly.) heroine is a drug that (once addicted.) the body demands.

    In lay man's terms, once you become addicted to heroine, the issue is (probably around 80%+ of the time.) totally out of the addicts control.

    People like the twat politician can easily sit there posing the question, "are you not responsible for your actions?" Obviously, "yes".

    However, it's a FACT of life that once a person is addicted to heroine, that person needs professional expertise and help, to help address their issue(s). Hence why, preaching "abstinence" to a crack or smack head is just bang out of order.

    So, telling a smack head "don't ever inject/smoke smack again" It's a little bit like saying to a banker, sat at his desk, "don't make any more money again." Well that's impossible. Like the drug addict, he/she is addicted to making money. Like the drug addict, they will also carry on their addiction/love affair regardless of the effects their addiction might have on their marriage, relationship with their kids and society in general. Regardless of their consequences, they will continue to make money and at any cost.

    Like a drug addict, It's what they're NOW programmed to do.

  59. Laurie Orr

    Why are you guys hating on Russell Brand? His perspective on drug addiction is spot on. The majority of people who become addicted to drugs & alcohol are living in hell. What starts as a way to escape personal pain ultimately brings more pain and hopelessness. Addicts don't use drugs, the drugs use them. Addiction takes everything from you until you are used up and empty. Recovery is a gift, the chance to get out. But it's not easy and for some , the process of facing the deep pain that is stiil there can be frightening & overwhelming. Abstinence from drug use moves an addict toward clarity, to face down the trauma & the hurt that the drugs & alcohol were masking. It requires a tremendous strength & resolve to stay clean & sometimes people don't make it. Very tragic I believe. I appreciate that Russell is using his celebrity voice to help others to move out of the darkness and to believe that there is hope.

  60. sta8ce

    this documentary is a one sided dogmatic *look at my view and my view only* pile of crap. and brand? on his way to certain death? uh hu.
    what 99% of these comments fail to recognize, realize, or understand is that addicts - real addics - have changed the way their brains function. this is fact. most addicts are well on their way by their teens - crucial changes never happen, however horrible changes do.
    (i'm not talking about a 6 month pill popper....)
    i know because i've done this to myself. to make the claim abstinence is the only real is the most irresponsible thing this i*iot has done to date. if he "really cared" about addicts, he'd be open to all paths of *recovery* irrelivant of what the are - just as long as they are.
    to family members who've seen methadone or suboxone "destroy" loved ones - abstinence isn't some magical wonder. not when you're left craving and full of need....well after detox.....tearing you apart, 24/7 - you will just keep using. an addict will not stop until they're finished.....and for most, that outcome is just too scary to comprehend.

  61. Henrik

    i dont understand why he is against methadone/suboxone, he wants drug addiction to be treated as a medical condition, and how do you treat medical conditions? usually with medications, methadone/suboxone helps you stay away from opiates, im on it myself and it helps. ofc there are both ups and downs with it. but i rather be on suboxone than a heroin addict like i was

  62. Teri

    Methadone/Suboxone should be given to inpatients only and in a taper. The problem is when these meds are prescribed and addicts abuse these and then become addicted/dependent on these. Make sense?

  63. Entertainmentluvva

    great documentary

  64. Eddy

    Being against methadone as a treatment for addiction makes sense, as methadone is an addictive opiate. Yes, methadone "treatment" takes the addict away from the problems that come with the lifestyle of "street" drug addiction..but it doesnt treat addiction..just a safer more reliable source of opiates.

  65. Sabine

    McKegany says that a majority of the population isn't addicted… Not quite right, I would say. I see addiction as a means of compensation for something that is missing, emotionally, spiritually. I would argue a large majority of today's society is addicted in some ways or the other: to food, sugar, sex - you name it. His view on and definition of 'addiction' is too narrow… Great documentary!

  66. Julie

    I admire you for making this and stepping into such an issue with such a stigma. I agree with the person above....the majority of the population IS addicted to SOMETHING. It is ALL a MENTAL HEALTH ISSUE. THANK YOU!!!! Keep doing what you are doing!!!

  67. Recovering

    Most of you should consider yourselves very fortunate. It's pretty clear that most of the people posting opinions here are not alcoholics or addicts. It's easy to see the ones that are. There are certain 'truths' that exist, things you really can only understand, if you've gone through it. Some non addicts here are more knowledgeable than others. But lots of you simply don't and can't understand. And consider yourselves lucky, because going through addiction and recovery is the hardest thing someone can go through. I've been through a lot of crap in my life and getting better was way harder than anything I've done.

    My only fault with the documentary is that it is too short, it switches around and doesn't go deep enough into some of the areas. But it has the perspective of someone who knows what the hell they are talking about. Trust me on that. You may not want to believe what is said but most if it is very true.

    The 5% comment. I've heard this too, years ago, when I was digging up evidence to protect myself from having to join a cult. Well, after relapsing enough times to surrender, it's clear that the low numbers represent failure of individuals to be honest, committed, open to complete the program. So criticize how hard it is to get better, less so the program. Because if someone actually commits to it, the numbers are much better. It's all about whether the person actually does the work required, not enough do. And as far as being sucked in and dependent the rest of your life, yeah, it IS the rest of your life, it has to be. But that doesn't mean being heavily involved in the program like sheep, people should do what they have to do, for some, they need perpetual structure to help them stay together. If nothing more, it's a fall back so they eventually really get well. I know people that have not used for 7 years that are as much a user as they were they day before they entered a program. They still have work to do but at least they aren't out committing crimes.

    Support groups. These support groups are the ONLY way recovery can work. The power in them lies in being around others who have empathy, they inherently understand what you are talking about. Going to a program of psychologists etc, that may work for some, but it really loses its power unless the people you are in there with have gone through it.

    Re: "True addicts can't be helped, get clean, abstinence can't work". Not true. I've seen it work. How someone reaches abstinence, whether it's cold turkey or whether they need medical assistance to do it safely, these are the only questions. But the end result has to be abstinence, at least for true addicts. And it has to be for life, however the person can do that. People ask me in social situations whether it's hard to be 'around it'. For me, it can't be. I look at a bottle of beer as a death sentence, a loaded gun to my mouth. Because I know that I can't have one drink…EVERY. I know that odds are likely that I'll be drinking 2 fifths a day within a month, on the road to death. I know because I've been through it. And I've tried it all, cold turkey, "controlled drinking". These may work for some, but not for me and probably not for others like me. Replacing one drug with another changes the problem, it doesn't solve it.

  68. Tabby

    Recovering,
    It isn't about support groups it's about legalizing drugs. When people realize that some can do drugs for socializing and others can't. I recently viewed the Russel Brown documentary on the stop to war on drugs and it made me realize that I will always want to be an addict however i choose not to be. That I believe is the hardest part. Whatever for some people, makes you feel good in life is bad. But be careful where that saying is used. Some people have found many other forms of life other than alcohol and drugs that give them that same feeling believe it or not. I know I have a a hard time believing it!

  69. Tabby

    I forgot to say it is a mental health issue and people need help! Just as if you had depression or anxiety . drug addiction is the same!

  70. Tabby

    I only hope that Russel Brand would contact me one day on drug abuse in Canada and discover that it happens all over the world. I have tried to contact him and say that the war on drugs is not over. It wont ever be because of reasons I cannot discuss on the internet or I will get blocked if I don't already. It is too bad that celebrities make films but then they don't communicate with the people that understand them oh well

  71. Tabby

    And I just have to say we as tax payers pay for people to be in the judicial system and for what? I have had a close member go through that system and it didn't help them. I don't want to start on that topic except to sat the system is not beneficial and we need to rehtink our strategies in helping the community because I work with people like that everyday and not the person directly but their children and it isn't fair what they have to go through it is survival mode and it sucks!

  72. Cindy sheets

    Russell I watched your film on addiction and was very impressed with your speech to parliament. I have struggled most of my 54 years with drugs and alcohol. Rehab 3 times (1 was court ordered). Abstinent 2 years then 4 years. I was severely injured and prescribed hydrocodone, Vicodin ES, etc. I became addicted of course. I was also drinking. I decided go get on Methadone. For almost five years I did drink. Doing other drugs ( opiates) on top DOES NOT WORK! Unless it's a very low dose it's simply addictive behavior and wishful thinking! Anyway, the alcohol stopped and the other drugs ( mostly cocaine) had ended after an arrest years before the methadone started. Today, I have a a good bank account, I'm an investor ( stocks, bonds, an artist- a good one too! AND I have owned my small farm with horses, dog and cats all since starting on Methadone. I mention this because in your film you constantly said that EVERYONE needs to be completely abstinent to reach their potential. That they are under the influence of drugs while on methadone and will stay in place. That simply IS NOT TRUE FOR ALL ADDICTS RUSSELL! I will agree that a lot of people abuse the program ( methadone) for that matter look at the failure rate of AA and NA! I'm simply saying you are being predjudice about methadone...it DOES work for some people

  73. Klaus

    Phantastic documentary. I watched it recently in a rehab in SouthAfrica. Specifically the adressing of us addicts as people with a deadly incurable desease / or us more seen as criminals of our actions. Difficult though from point of view of victims, family and friends. And I agree with Russel: Best is to find, however that will be possible a way of life without fokkin substances! Anything else, my humble observation in about 25 years active using, anything else will take my back to my cave... Why not sell dope in supermarkets? Or rocks? The whole discussion legal , illegal is crap anyway. U will get anything anywhere, whateer age u r, its somehow ridiculous to try and contain that via draconic rules. My friends in thailand, where u do have death penalty still for drug related crimes, still traffic and do as they please despite "possibility of near death experiences...hahaha" so please...wake up! Unfortunately as an addict I wont wake up unless something really painful happens to me, so painful that even drugs are not an option any more. Which was for me not death, severe psychotic episodes, violence nor imprisonment. Its kindof intimate...

  74. Sorsha

    Abstinence, huh? Save us please ! ! This guy is into self promotion and I would not be surprised to learn he has narcissistic, emotionally unstable personality disorder, craves attention, and wouldn't be above falsifying facts to promote himself for personal gain. I came across drug addicts in my career - the long and the short of it was that there were no "resources" apart from rare inpatient detox clinics but no community follow-up (absolutely vital component missing). The "clients" were frequently referred to other community resources unable to take them as their criteria did not fit. I watched people beg, implore for help. They could only go so far themselves. Only one in nine can make it. RB's story sounds far fetched; that is to say multiple addictions class "A" drugs. He probably still abuses substances but to a lesser degree.

  75. Andy

    I'm a card carrying member of AA and it is not a cult. The courts might you send you there for a period of time but it is purely a choice if you remain there. Nothing is forced on you while you are there. It is purely suggestive. Atheist and agnostic are welcomed. Their primary purpose is to help people get sober. You can come and go anytime you like. To say anything opposite of that about the program would also suggest that you don't know what you are talking about. Maybe that you are a tad uneducated and maybe have a problem yourself. The program works if you work it.

Leave a comment / review: