World War I: American Legacy

2006 ,    »  -   32 Comments
193
8.36
12345678910
Ratings: 8.36/10 from 149 users.
Storyline
World War I: American Legacy

Narrated by David Carradine, this poignant film reveals the true cost of World War I. The forgotten soldiers whose graves were never marked, the expense of human life and the immense suffering of those who did survive (for every man who was killed, three men were maimed, injured or driven mad). World War I sucked up millions of dollars and swamped many governments in debt. Estimates of cost amount to a staggering $190 billion dollars. But how did this diabolical destruction commence? How did the 'Great War' come to the front doorstep of the United States?

It began with two pivotal murders. Archduke Franz Ferdinand, the heir to the Austro-Hungarian Empire and his wife Sophie were murdered publicly by activists in the city of Sarajevo. The Austro-Hungarians declared war when the Serbians refused to allow their officials to investigate the murders. The situation escalated when the surrounding allied countries became involved. Russia came to the aid of the Serbians and the Germans supported the Austro-Hungarians. On Aug 1 1914, the Germans declared war on Russia. As the British would not tolerate a mobilized German army so close to them across the English Channel, the Great British Empire declared war after the German army invaded Belgium on Aug 4 1914. Thus starts the 'war to end all wars'.

The Americans stayed out of the war, but provided ammunition and finance. At sea, Germany declared that any ship carrying war supplies to Britain or France would be targeted and destroyed. German submarines subsequently attacked and sunk many American cargo ships. When British code breakers intercepted a German message to the Mexican government, it was given directly to the Americans. This message contained the potential threat of a secret alliance between the Germans and Mexicans. The United States of America is then compelled to declare war against Germany on 6 April 1917.

14 million people lost their lives during the 'The Great War' and a generation of young men had been wiped out. This 'war to end all wars' was so awful; that it was believed it could never again be repeated. Although World War I hasn't had as much attention as other wars, (such as World War II or the Vietnam War), it has still left a profound impact on the lives of Americans to this day.

32 Comments / User Reviews

  1. tim

    A beautiful tribute to brave men and women, yet as many historians note if they had not gone the war would have ended on more balanced terms with the Germans and world war II probably would never have happened

  2. Horst Manure

    Also makes you wonder what the world population would be now.??

  3. James

    I haven't watched this yet, but how America-centric is this? As the description said, America stayed out of the war. I'm British; my grandparents didn't. And I've seen a few America-centric documentaries that seem to ignore the suffering of everyone who isn't American, focussing on how it changed them. If that's the case, I'd rather not watch it.

  4. ameagher2 .

    Don't rely on the opinion of others ... be brave.

  5. James

    Ha, good answer. But time is money. And data is money. And I don't have money to waste.

    I just want to know if every third word is "America" and every fifth word "freedom".

  6. bringmeredwine

    Some moving words were read about all the soldiers, penned by an American named Father Duffy. More from Americans who admired their French comrades and fought in the French army.
    It's not so bad.......

  7. bringmeredwine

    I enjoyed this doc because I am interested by both world wars history. This video was better than I thought it would be.
    Carradine presented very moving stories, together with illustrations and photographs,about the Americans in Europe during the war: The writers, musicians, famous scions, also about groups like the SOS, and the 169th, to name a few.
    I made it almost to the end until Carradine began recounting the animal "war heroes" stories. Pretty silly I know, considering all that was happening to the humans.

  8. James

    Thanks! :)

  9. bringmeredwine

    You're welcome.
    My Grampa served in WW1, under age, in Britain.
    He was a farm boy from Ontario, Canada.
    Like all his friends, he thought the great war would be a wonderful adventure!

  10. James

    That's amazing! There are a few old British chaps in my village who served... Don't talk much about it though. Seems to be a recurring theme.

  11. bringmeredwine

    Grampa was haunted by the horror of it all.
    He was trained outside of London as a telegraph operator and relayed all the death notifications back to head quarters.
    Did the same job in Winnipeg as a civilian, during WW 2.
    He learned of all the local boys who'd died before their families did.
    He was a lovely gentle man though, in spite of it all.
    My Dad and an Uncle served for Canada in WW 2. They talked about the "fun" times, all the pranks they'd pull and the partying; but never about the horror of it all.
    I think back then the men had to appear very stoic and put on a brave face about their service. (Or became raging alcoholics!)

  12. Noel Brett

    no mate its actually not ..very poignant actually with all nations affected given more than a mention.

  13. Horst Manure

    Wonder what the world population would be now if we did not have wars????

  14. NJ

    An incrediible summarization of a complex buildup toward a world war from long buried enemies now excited about ending old feuds without the foresite of its outcome. Subtopics and intimate narriatives offer historical visual, sound, film, and photography in addition to addressing gender, race, ethnicity, animal usage, communication, and air and ground industrialization growth at hyper speed.

    Covert and overt comparisons help a viewer see poor officer leadership and those officers that fought side-by-side with their troops. Most tragic is trench warfare taking men to no-man's land over and over again from those in high command, some never seeing first-hand the hell holes. There is no rationale given for going up and out of the trench as none seems to exist.

    The documentary offers a clear introduction of cause and effect ending in carrying over of unfinished business still with us today. The irony here is similar to the the buried fueds that expanded into a world war.

  15. Scott Caputo

    Probably about the same... a better question would be "wonder how many people would be on the planet Earth today if there was no Flu, Malaria, or Starvation"

  16. Archie Caldwell

    As long as thereis man there will be war

  17. Archie Caldwell

    disease wud control pop

  18. Archie Caldwell

    I wonder how many people wud be here if there was no religion

  19. Archie Caldwell

    It was pure hell

  20. Archie Caldwell

    Strange Everyhone who went to war "lied" about there age. Were they brain dead?

  21. Archie Caldwell

    How cud he be haunted by it ? he had a cushy job sening Morse code. jeesh
    Out side LOndon??? Another cushy job
    Dont embellish a story that doesnt exist
    If he was in London he wud feel the bombs But he was not in London
    He wasnt even in the dam war. jeesh
    He had a cushy job receiving n sending morse code

  22. bringmeredwine

    WW1 he gave four years of his life for the British Commonwealth and it's allies.
    He didn't just magically arrive outside of London one day and work from a first class salon.
    He was a young, naïve farm boy who'd never been anywhere else in his life.
    What do you suppose he was doing in Europe before he was selected to be a telegraph operator?
    He was fighting for his life in hell, with everybody else.
    Go boil your head!

  23. Horst Manure

    Looks like some thing got your English teacher.

  24. Scott Caputo

    probably less.. that seems to be the goal of godless communism, abortion, gay marriage, and sterilization. All liberal atheistic agendas. Catholicism, Mormonism, Islam, and Hinduism and many more religions promote large families and no birth control. So how do you feel about the population now?

  25. Shaving Pvt. Ryan

    I just stopped reading at the description, didnt even watch the documentary:

    "The Austro-Hungarians declared war when the Serbians refused to allow their officials to investigate the murders."
    The Austro-Hungarians' ultimatum contained 10 (ten!) bullet points which Serbia had to accept.
    Inviting austrian detectives to inspect the arch duke's murder was not a problem.

    This is bulls*it american propaganda I can already smell it. Just hope people dont take this too seriously.

  26. IGetItAlready

    Not only were there I believe 15 demands made of the Serbians by the Habsburg empire, but they were of such a nature as to ensure Serbia would not agree. In addition, the Austrian ambassador to Serbia was instructed that if the Serbs did comply, he was to refuse to accept Serbia's acceptance of the ultimatum.

    But, as I'm absolutely fascinated with WWI, I'm still going to give it a watch just to see what's up.

  27. IGetItAlready

    Good call Pvt. Ryan.
    This is by no means a historical study.
    Rather, it sticks pretty literally to it's title in that it focuses on a handful of Americans to have served and their own personal lives and "legacies".
    And unfortunately, even if that were the type of thing I were interested in, I'd have to give this documentary a pretty low rating due entirely to it's still image, slideshow format and the dismal narration that fails in it's efforts for the dramatic with needlessly poetic language from a very boring narrator who induces drowsiness despite his forced inflection.

    The only upside is the inclusion of a few very interesting photos and paintings of the carnage that I had not seen before.
    But again, with these images fading into the next every few seconds and the tiresome droning of the narrator, you'll soon find yourself dozing.

  28. IGetItAlready

    With all due respect, I vehemently disagree.

    "An incrediible summarization of a complex buildup toward a world war
    from long buried enemies now excited about ending old feuds without the
    foresite of its outcome."

    In that one astoundingly broad and erroneous claim, the spelling errors aside, you've stated more about the buildup proceeding WWI than this film ever even attempts.

  29. Horst Manure's Dad

    wars make the world go round

  30. Horst Manure

    The rich and the military are the only winners.

  31. Margie

    I found this documentary mesmerizing and very well done. I now have a much better understanding of WW I and with the notes I took, a list of resources that I can delve deeper into. I also disagree with the person who complained about the tribute to the thousands of animals who helped the soldiers and gave their lives. These animals were not there by choice and deserve recognition.

  32. Roger Andout

    Still people will judge a documentary by it's blurb and, no doubt, justify this for not viewing it but still comment on something they have not watched. Next thing they'll be book burning. Sorry, my last remark may be inflammatory to some.

Leave a comment / review: