Promises
Promises presents a powerful portrait of seven Palestinian and Israeli children who live in and around Jerusalem. As filmmaker B.Z. Goldberg, who was raised in Israel, notes, They live no more than 20 minutes from each other, but they are each growing up in very separate worlds. The children include Mahmoud, Shlomo, Sanabel, Faraj, Moishe, and twins Yarko and Daniel.
With the exception of the latter, all are religious (the twins are the grandchildren of a Holocaust survivor). Most have strong political beliefs and have seen their share of tragedy - Faraj's friend was killed in front of him--but as the film makes clear, they're also kids.
They like to watch TV, hold burping contests, and compete in sports (Faraj is a runner, Yarko and Daniel play volleyball). Promises doesn't attempt to explain them, but lets the kids speak for themselves. The results are funny, sad, and ultimately quite profound.
If you believe in your heart that, despite every hurdle, peace is possible between the Israelis and Palestinians, this film will fill you with hope and wonder. That's not to say it's rosy - the children depicted in the film often exhibit anger and intolerance, but the mere act of recognition between the children of these two warring groups is enough to inspire faith in their futures. This film is a beautiful document of a precious, brave and tenuous experiment on the part of the filmmakers. May we all have the courage to try to guide the next generation into a more peaceful, more understanding world.
lol, I got sad when Yarko and Daniel joined the army :( but I loved the movie, very motivating :) we're even doing a debate in class about who should keep the land....I got Israel, but I don't really know who should keep it...both have very good and strong reasons why. Ugh, my debate is tomorrow, wish me luck!
sad when kid dies best friend dies
good movie but sad
good
We the human beings could never learn to live like human beings.the most important ingredient of this life was love for the fellow human beings,but factual position is that human beings have brought more ruin to human beings than any other creature could.media can still help us.
Oh my god I cried so much...
I need peace so so much, noone in the world can know that. Like daniel said, they'll say yes we want it too, but they can't know how I feel and how much me and all my people need it. Even if they're children, but most of the israeli children I saw here seemed to me very intolerant, except the twins. If only God existed, he wouldn't let that happen or at least would have stopped it.
I'm learning hebrew now to be able to speak to israelis, but I still didn't meet any peaceful israeli. Please God, if you exist, my mother needs peace and may my father, killed by israeli soldiers, rest in peace.
I cried so badly when I saw this documentary, in the rally of the news we forget the children that get caught up in the crossfire of this madness.
i do,
those kids rule!
if only all jewish & arab, can settle this with who can better burp in ur face,...wata wonderfull world . . .
Burping. . . .Priceless . .
so sad and just wish one day theres peace respect all
All such beautiful and brave children
Shlomo seems so wise for his age
I wish things were different, I feel so sorry for all the people in the film. The greatest advantage of the film for me is that it explains the conflict in a simple and human way - I think that few people in Europe and other parts of the world really understand what's going on there and what the basis of the conflict is. Being from Poland, where the memories of Holocaust are still alive, I can't help thining that you just can't give up fighting for peace. The people who live next door, even if they're your enemies do not differ that much in fact. You just need to try understand that, leave all the past behind (like we did with Germans) and start everything from the beginning. If you keep looking back, you'll never be able to bury the hatchet.
I wish this film (and the youtube clips of some the kids more grown up) could be shown throughout Israel and Palestine. Even though it takes place some years ago, in some ways, I think things - in particular, communication - has perhaps gotten worse. I love this documentary because of its honesty - because not everything is perfect and in reality, this conflict - like so many others - is quite complex. I also like how this documentary doesn't pretend to have the answers, but is doing something so important and courageous by really exploring some of the many different worlds we live in here, giving them real faces, personalities, and stories - and trying to bring them together. Our past, present, and future are so intertwined and connected ... we can't continue to live in separate worlds. It is only harming us all.
Awesome Documentary... These kind of stuffs can really bring Peace, I can say that confidentially by the grace of God !
What a Lovely Documentary. It's sad to know the Twins have eventually joined the Army. It begs the question, What good has come out of the interaction between the two sides? There will be no peace with a majority of Israeli civilians knowing the occupation is wrong in it's entirety then growing up to have adopted completely different views, the worst part is the twins have seen how these Palestinian refugees live, why is it so hard for Israeli's I wonder. Greed, insecurity, Incompassion, Arrogance has easily taken the toll of them I guess. The Israeli civilians will always live in fear and will also and probably always be armed, this, of course will not bring any good, rather, it will produce more soldiers and hence, continue the conflict. It's amazing how even with their Soldiers they still live in fear, it's simple, you know the way they say 'you can't give what you don't have'?..well in this case, you can't have what you don't deserve.
it litteraly made me cry.. being an israeli girl it touched my heart in ways i didnh think it could. Beautiful story, its just sucks that so many kids, including myself, are brought up to hate the other side of the fence even though we dont even know what its like over there... we assume and dont explore other peoples opinios and feelings.
such a touching documentary! loved it. i understand the reasons behind this war just a little more now.
This documentary was very well done. I was introduced to it by my history teacher and absolutely loved it. While all the children seemed very intelligent and well spoken, the twin boys Yarko & Daniel had beautiful insight for their age.
Great doco. Lovely kids. Peace is in Northern Ireland. It can happen between Israel and Palestine. Just needs humbleness.
Do the Palestinians really have clocks with hands going backwards!?
I loved the documentary, it was really especial. Hey does anyone knows what's the name of the song in the minute 1:28:15 when they're at the park playing soccer??? I'd like to get it! Thanks.
Do u have pictures of the kids as u were filming?
This movie was very touching. Not only did it show how children brought up from this kind of environment are raised to hate each other, it also showed their purest and softest sides that if given the chance they would like to play and interact with one another. But as all humans, we are pressured to follow the kind of cultures we are born in even if they are clearly not the right path and our hearts does not really really want it for ourselves.
I am Palestinian. my grand father run away from Palestine in 47 to Egypt. I've always lived abroad. I ve never visited Palestine, but Palestine always lived in me , because of the family history i carry.
I can have some things in common with those Palestinian kids, even though i've never lived there lives and had their experiences and most of all didn't live their day to day fears and lack of freedom.
* Because of living far from my homeland and not even getting the chance of visiting it ever. I felt the same as this palestinian child, who can't cross the check points to go back on the land where his ancestors lived.
*Because of hearing the history of my family and how they lost their homes, and members of the family. I feel like this Palestinian kid, that feels the unfairness towards the jews , that confiscated their land and lived on it.
*Because of having the opportunity of meeting jew people, through my foreign (french) education . I realised just like those palestinian kids, that not all jews are haters and killers of palestinians. Just like not all palestinians are terrorists.
So before, we should think about peace..like those kids from both sides (even the most religious one) I think that the key is COMMUNICATING.
But unfortunatly there is something that could never be erased from both sides, the sadness and the grudge . That will always push some to extreme moves to feel "free" and legitimate.
All of that to say ..: this documentary is more then real.It shows that no matter what barrier you put between people, dialogue is ALWAYS POSSIBLE.