Ashley Smith: Out of Control

2010, Crime  -   9 Comments
Ratings: 7.11/10 from 19 users.

The Fifth Estate documentary series exposes the cracks in the Canadian prison system in Ashley Smith: Out of Control, a harrowing and provocative investigation into the unfortunate death of a young inmate.

Smith was adopted shortly after her birth. Her home was like that of any traditional loving family. Her behavioral problems began with the onset of puberty, and were marked by episodes of defiance and poor school performance. After pelting a mailman with crabapples, she was incarcerated for assaulting a public employee. What was designed to be a short sentence stretched into a number of years and multiple institutions. Her journey eventually concluded with her tragic suicide inside Grand Valley Institution in Kitchener, Ontario.

The centerpiece of the film is never-before-seen surveillance footage that shows Smith undergoing a string of physical punishments at the hands of prison guards, including painful dousings of pepper spray, 23 hours a day in solitary confinement, a lack of adequate toiletries, and barbaric constraint.

Smith clearly suffered from some form of undiagnosed mental illness. The prison system was ill prepared to deal with her unruliness; in fact, the disciplinary abuses she suffered only exacerbated her already fragile state. Astonishingly, Smith's treatment in these prisons was touted as therapeutic. It's clear that she did not receive the level of compassionate rehabilitation that could have transformed the course of her life.

In the course of their investigation, the filmmakers speak with Smith's grief stricken parents, a fellow inmate and correctional institution officials. Together, they paint a vivid portrait of a flesh and blood young girl overwhelmed by the delirium in her mind, the apathy of her captures, and the hell of her environment.

Smith's story is not unique. Mentally ill inmates are frequently moved from prison to prison across the Canadian landscape. Their mental instability is further unhinged by inhumane treatment, which often inspires them to commit more and more drastic offenses. It's a vicious cycle that betrays the purpose of reformation.

Ashley Smith: Out of Control is a probing indictment of a badly broken system, and a highly disturbing account of one of its victims.

More great documentaries

9 Comments / User Reviews

  1. Victoria Nope

    Btw, who's been the one to put the child to Canada, hm?

  2. Victoria Nope

    The child was "a beast" the parents taught to. No need to cry.

  3. cmh

    every outburst this child had was a cry for help and because she was thrown in the system, she never was able to get the help she needed. everyone involved should have been able to see that she needed more than being locked up and the fact that they never even evaluated her mental state absolutely disgusts me. the sad truth is that this is a reality for so many mentally ill prisoners. from the moment you enter the system you are nothing more than a number til the day you die.

  4. Sharky

    The parents are blaming Corrections for not helping her, why didnt they help her at home before she ever entered prison?

  5. TD

    I actually think keeping someone like this separated from the population saved innocent lives. She was a time bomb that would have hurt or killed her parents or anyone who crossed her path. IMO

  6. John

    This is an example of why you cannot trust systems. They are inadequate. All of them: prison, mental health, school, medical.
    This is why a famous English linguist said the 9 worst words in the English language are: "We're from the government and we're here to help".

  7. Then C

    The best hope for someone like her is the parent's love. If that fails, no one can help except Him. I think He intervened.

  8. Donna

    Absolutely MORTIFYING! Absolutely BARBARIC! And there's no doubt in my mind that this treatment happens in the U.S. also. You can bet your butt, I would have went into that cell, no matter if I had lost my job. And for the guards that ended up getting their jobs back? Who is their right mind would even want to go back? She basically was severely abused by these guards and the prison system, for throwing crabapples at a mailman. Utterly and totally disgusted by the way she was treated.

  9. Roma Fraser-Engler

    Out of control apparently are mental health care professions - educational systems - christian leaders - fighting for control of a human being over money - This young girl' soul was in distress a common occurrence at puberty. W5 investigated Del Vee Delores Williams Morgan private programming versus Government run facilities that could not buy the program Del Vee for autism . These statements are made without prejudice are true based upon the best accurate written data to date . There are times when GOD knows best.